Return to my Puzzle pages
Go to
my home page
© Copyright 2000, Jim Loy
See my other articles on Word Arithmetics:
Sometimes you can study a seemingly difficult word arithmetic puzzle for a while, and then get a perfect insight to solve it in one swoop.
Part I - This is a puzzle like that:
ABC
------
DAE)FEGHBH
FBDB
----
IADB
IGFA
----
CJEH
BCGB
----
FHD
I see one clue right away: AxE=...B, and BxE=...A. I know from doing these puzzles that there are several combinations that work that way, especially when E is 9. But, I see a better clue. AxE=...B and A+E=...B. Off hand, I couldn't think of any combinations that work that way. Let's draw a multiplication table (note that A is not equal to E, also A and E are not equal to zero):
A = 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
-----------------
E = 1 | 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
2 | 2 6 8 0 2 4 6 8
3 | 3 6 2 5 8 1 4 7
4 | 4 8 2 0 4 8 2 6
5 | 5 0 5 0 0 5 0 5
6 | 6 2 8 4 0 2 8 4
7 | 7 4 1 8 5 2 6 3
8 | 8 6 4 2 0 8 6 2
9 | 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2
We see that there are only two possible solutions 4x8=8x4=...2 and 4+8=8+4=...2. Now we can use our other clue, BxE=...A to eliminate one of these two possible solutions. And the puzzle is easy from there.
The solution:
823
------
784)645929
6272
----
1872
1568
----
3049
2352
----
697 Part II - Here is another puzzle, which seems difficult at first:
AB
-----
CDEF)BGHGF
GDIC
----
EGCJF
EGEEH
----
EAJ
Any clues? How about these:
These facts simplify the puzzle tremendously. They limit A (2, 3, or 4), E (1, 2, 3, or 4), and C (2, 3, or 4):
C=2234
E=1112
A=3422
We can eliminate the last column, as E and A cannot both be 2. So E=1. AxF=?C, which eliminates the third column (where A is even and C is odd), so C=2. And we can limit possible values of F:
C=222
E=111
A=344
F=438
A+E=J or A+E=J+1, giving us possible values of J, and those give us G and H:
C=22222
E=11111
A=34444
F=43388
J=55656
G=77878
H=98732
We can eliminate the last column. And if H is odd then F cannot be even. That eliminates two more columns:
C=22
E=11
A=44
F=33
J=56
G=78
H=87
We now know C, E, A, and F. Let's put those into the puzzle:
4B
-----
2D13)BGHG3
GDI2
----
1G2J3
1G11H
----
14J
I is 5, which makes J=6, G=8, and H=7:
4B
-----
2D13)B8783
8D52
----
18263
18117
----
146
Finally, B=9 and D=0. And that solves the puzzle.
Part III - This one is easy. Try it. You may have trouble at first. But there are many clues:
AB
-----
CDDE)FGABD
HGIE
----
JIBD
JFEE
----
ABD
The following clues should be obvious: E=0, J=9, B=5, A is even, and D is even. Also C=1, as 5xCDDE is a four digit number. D=8, as no other number works for 5x1DD0=9F00. A<5 as H<J=9. So A=2 or 4. A=4 doesn't work with Ax1880=HGI0. So A=2. And the rest is simple.
Part IV - This one is very easy, if you notice a certain clue. Try it:
ABC
-------
DABE)EDBFFGC
EHGCE
------
HABIG
HBCAG
------
HFHJC
HGEHJ
-----
GFC
First of all, J=0, C=5, A=6, and E is even. The puzzle looks a little daunting after that. But, E can be deduced immediately. 6xBE=...5E. So 6xE must have an odd carry. 6x2 is the only such number left. So E=2. Then B=4. The rest of the puzzle is easy.
Comment: A few months ago, Dell provided a page of Word Arithmetics that did not spell words or sentences, like mine, as an experiment for their serious Word Arithmetic fans. Unfortunately, most of the puzzles were ridiculously easy.